1. Pastor F. B. Slater ……………………………………………….. January 1942 – April 1942
2. Pastor Frank L. Bland ………………………………………….. May 1942 – June 1946
3. Pastor M. A. Burgess …………………………………………… July 1946 – December 1948
4. Pastor A. V. Pinkney …………………………………………….. January 1949 – June 1952
5. Pastor C. D. Brooks …………………………………………….. July 1952 – September 1953
6. Pastor U. S. Willis ……………………………………………….. October 1953 – December 1954
7. Pastor G. E. Peters ……………………………………………… January 1955 – December 1956
8. Pastor C. L. Brooks …………………………………………….. January 1957 – March 1961
9. Pastor Leon G. Cox …………………………………………….. April 1961 – June 1963
10. Pastor William DeShay …………………………………………. July 1963 – December 1964
11. Pastor Edward Dorsey …………………………………………. July 1964 – December 1966
12. Pastor A. S. Wagner ……………………………………………. January 1967 – March 1970
13. Pastor John Damon …………………………………………….. April 1970 – August 1971
14. Pastor L. Hernandez ……………………………………………. September 1971 – December 1973
15. Pastor E. L. Richardson ……………………………………….. January 1974 – January 1976
16. Pastor G. L. Braxton ……………………………………………. February 1976 – December 1987
Pastor Carl Hinds …………………………………………… 1986 (Associate)
Pastor J. I. Broomfield …………………………………….. 1987 (Associate)
17. Pastor S. G. Campbell …………………………………………. January 1988 – February 1995
18. Pastor H. Kibble ………………………………………………….. March 1995 – September 1998
19. Pastor S. Peter Campbell ……………………………………… October 1998 – August 2006
20. Pastor Carl Hinds ………………………………………………… August 2006 – July 2010
21. Pastor Colin Brathwaite, Jr. (Interim) ……………………… August 2010 – September 2013
22. Pastor Dr. Gary Banks …………………………………………. October 2013 – September 2015
23. Pastor William Taliaferro ……………………………………… October 2015 – December 2021
Pastor David DeFoe ………………………………………. 2022 (Interim)
24. Pastor Dr. Ronald D. Williams, Jr ……………………………. August 2022 – October 2025
25. Pastor Jovan Whyte ……………………………. March 2026 – Present